|
Begging The Question
|
||||
|
Wednesday, May 06, 2009
The website for the St. Petersburg Times -- make that the two-Pulitzers-winning St. Pete Times -- has an interesting new addition. It's a prominent link to a site called Tampa Bay Mug Shots. It's pretty much what it says -- a site providing mugshots for local arrestees. The main St. Pete Times site shows the three most recent check-ins at the Crossbar Hotel.
I'll admit the site is fascinating to scroll through, especially with the search options. My favorite so far is the meth head being help upright by a jailer wearing plastic gloves. But it's also a little unpleasant. Why does this site exist? It claims to be a "public service," but it's also clearly something of a shaming sanction. I'm not sure how this site serves the public. The mug shots themselves, and the information about the charges, are already publicly available on the counties' websites. If you want to look up a specific person, that's easy enough. Who needs to see every arrestee? Are they trying to make this a Felony Facebook? Misdemeanor MySpace? And the problem with calling this a shaming sanction is the simple fact that none of these people are guilty of anything yet. Sure, most of them will end up with a conviction, but not all. In addition, posting some of these mugshots on the main newspaper website implies that the arrests are newsworthy, and most aren't. All in all, while I agree the site is interesting in the same way The Smoking Gun's mugshot collection is, I'm not convinced it should be promoted as the next example of fine public service journalism from an established paper or its affiliated website. Tuesday, May 05, 2009
Alternative Post Title: Procrastination is always the right answer
Quiet Sun May Trigger Global Cooling I encourage everyone to trade in their hybrids for large SUVs and construction grade pickup trucks. We also need an immediate ban on all wind and solar energy plants. The time for debate is over. If you love your planet... if you love your children... you must warm the planet. The alternative, polar bears overrunning New England, leg warmers coming back in fashion, and an exponential increase in Curling, are just too terrible to imagine. Monday, May 04, 2009
Fresh off of taking 3 years to finish my previous book, I managed to get through this last one in about a month. Part of that is me spending more time reading. Most of it is going from a 1000 page small print biography to a 300 page large print book with lots of pictures and side notes.
For those unfamiliar, Mysteries of the Middle Ages is part of the continuing "lynchpins of history" series by Thomas Cahill. Previous editions in the series include How the Irish Saved Civilization, The Gifts of the Jews, Desire of the Everlasting Hills, and Sailing the Wine Dark Seas. Of these I have only read the Irish book, which was very enjoyable. As one who enjoys those points in history where a singular event can determine the course of a people, I was looking forward to this book. With that lead in, I was a little disappointed. It wasn't a bad book. To the contrary it contained a number of interesting bits of trivia. Many facinating details about well known figures like Thomas Aquinas, plus the stories of lesser known personalities like Peter Aberland, Hildegard, and Eleanor of Aquitaine. One of the more interesting chapters had to to with the rise of the "modern" university, and how the study of the Christian sacrament gave rise to modern science. What disappointed was the disjointedness of the book. There was no flow. At one point the author even realizes this, and states to the reader that the book is all over the place because that's the way the Middle Ages were. While I don't disagree, it would've been easier to group certain themes together, or made more of a point of how the stories he picked related to each other. The overarching theme he tries to tie through the book is the persistant philosophies of Plato and Aristotle, and how the pendulum swings back and forth between them. How the focus changes from the heavenly/ideal to the worldly/accessable. And the fact the western world is, and always has been, basically a Greek creation. Another irksome aspect is the author's penchant for interjecting his personal politics. He does it very openly and honestly, and does not try to sneak it in by selective fact selection or narrative manipulation. The first time he did it in the book, I was actually appreciative of the method he used. But then it happened again. And again. And again. When someone picks up a history book, they don't do it because they want to be preached to about modern policy. At the end of the book, the author lays out a list of characters he would have loved to talk about but didn't have the space. But the book wasn't that long, and had very large print (at least in paperback). He could have easily included these peoples' stories and still had a very readable book. And he couldn't have excluded them because they fell outside the non-existant storyline. All in all, not a waste of time. But in the end it felt much like a dark comedy that the trailers make to look like a regular comedy. When you watch the movie, even though it's good, it's not what you expected so you come away feeling overly critical. Next on the reading list, James Madison and the Struggle for the Bill of Rights. I'll get back to you on that in 3 years, give or take. |
Recent Posts Milbarge's links
How Appealing
Volokh Conspiracy Crescat Sententia Sugar, Mr. Poon? SCOTUSblog E. McPan Southern Appeal Stay of Execution S.W. Va. Law Blog CrimLaw Sentencing L&P Begging to Differ Prettier Than Napoleon Favorable Dicta The Yin Blog De Novo PG: HtSoM Centinel Hot Librarian Blonde Justice Althouse PrawfsBlawg Concurring Opinions Crime & Federalism Orin Kerr Is That Legal? Prof. Bainbridge Frolics & Detours AppellateLaw&Practice Right Coast Abstract Appeal Clearly Erroneous Fresh Pepper? Side Salad The Wishbone Jeremy Blachman Overheard/Office Naked Drinking Coffee Legally Blonde Legal Underground WSJ Law Blog The Slog Trivial Pusuits Still Angry Crooked Timber The Conglomerate Heldman: Ignatz Don't Let's Start Screaming Bean Heidi Bond Stag Blog Legal Quandary Divine Angst ObsessiveLawStudent Things Thrown The Imbroglio Signifying Nothing Stuart Buck Legal Fiction Under. Robes NRO's Corner New Republic Balkinization Election Law Blog Legal Theory Blog Legal Ethics Forum Ernie the Attorney Intel Dump Disability Law Bag & Baggage Between Lawyers Becker-Posner Lessig Blog Crim Prof Blog White Collar Crime Tax Prof Blog Grits for Breakfast All Deliberate Speed Adventures of Chester College Basketball Blog College Football News Nomination Nation Inter Alia Stateline The Note Wonkette The Onion Slate Atlantic RJYH: Fanopticon Freakonomics Vice Squad Indiana Law Blog Field of Schemes Questionable Content Dilbert Blog Toothpaste for Dinner Pathetic Geek Stories AIM: milbargebtq Yahoo: btqmilbarge Milbarge Recommends ![]() Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas
Site Feeds
Search
Disclaimer The views presented here are personal and in no way reflect the view of my employer. In addition, while legal issues are discussed here from time to time, what you read at BTQ is not legal advice. I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer. If you need legal advice, then go see another lawyer. Furthermore, I reserve (and exercise) the right to edit or delete comments without provocation or warning. And just so we're clear, the third-party comments on this blog do not represent my views, nor does the existence of a comments section imply that said comments are endorsed by me. Technical Stuff
| |||