Begging The Question

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Legal Miscellany
1. The Justice Department approved the proposed merger of the two satellite radio companies, XM and Sirius. The FCC still has to give the okay, but this is obviously a positive step towards completing the deal. I wrote in favor of the merger back here. (Disclosure: I'm an XM subscriber.) Here are contrasting takes from Reason's Radley Balko and the Washington Post's Steven Pearlstein.

2. The Supreme Court has granted a Fourth Amendment qualified immunity case to decide if it should overrule Saucier v. Katz. Some links, discussion, and details from Prof. Kerr at the VC here, and Prof. Althouse here. I have written about this issue a few times -- see here, here, and here. Most of that was in the context of the famous "Bong Hits 4 Jesus" case.

Basically, Saucier requires courts to determine first if the right in question in the suit was violated, and if so, to then determine if it was "clearly established" at the time. The most common criticism is that it's often easier to decide the latter question (and that avoids having to make a constitutional ruling). I support Saucier and wouldn't mind seeing its approach extended to other doctrines -- for example, Fourth Amendment cases (requiring a ruling on the merits before moving on to ask if good faith applies) and habeas cases (especially ineffective assistance of counsel cases, requiring a ruling on performance before moving on to prejudice). But it looks like it might not last much longer.

3. This week the Supreme Court decided Medellin v. Texas (link to long opinion available from SCOTUSBlog here), concerning the intersection of the treaty power, federalism, and state criminal procedural rules. I won't get into the merits, but I did notice that the opinion cited a precedent from 1884 called the Head Money Cases. I had never heard of this one before, but I'm sorry I missed it when I wrote a post asking "Where have all the Cases cases gone?" I'm still in favor of bringing back the "Cases" naming convention when appropriate, so I was happy to see this citation. Plus, it's just funny to say "the Head Money Cases."



Monday, March 24, 2008

More Stunning Revelations From the New York Governor's Office
Is there some kind of truth serum in the water in Albany? First we have ex-Gov. Eliot Spitzer's shocking downfall thanks to his patronization of a prostitution ring. Then the new Governor, David Paterson, admits he and his wife both had affairs years ago during a troubled point in their marriage. And now, Paterson reveals that he tried cocaine and marijuana in his youth. What other skeletons could possibly fit in the governor's mansion closets after all this?!

Well, the crack investigative team here at BTQ has unearthed the latest mind-blowing news from Gov. Paterson, a secret so incredible it must be heard in the man's own words:



Recent Posts

  • This blog has moved
  • ThunderCats!
  • Under Construction
  • The real question: Why am I reading this?
  • If I had my way, I would tear this whole building ...
  • Good enough for government work
  • The Me Decade (for the right price)
  • Cautiously Optimistic About 2010
  • 50 Book Challenge
  • Read something I wrote somewhere else!


  • Milbarge's links

    How Appealing
    Volokh Conspiracy
    Crescat Sententia
    Sugar, Mr. Poon?
    SCOTUSblog
    E. McPan
    Southern Appeal
    Stay of Execution
    S.W. Va. Law Blog
    CrimLaw
    Sentencing L&P
    Begging to Differ
    Prettier Than Napoleon
    Favorable Dicta
    The Yin Blog
    De Novo
    PG: HtSoM
    Centinel
    Hot Librarian
    Blonde Justice
    Althouse
    PrawfsBlawg
    Concurring Opinions
    Crime & Federalism
    Orin Kerr
    Is That Legal?
    Prof. Bainbridge
    Frolics & Detours
    AppellateLaw&Practice
    Right Coast
    Abstract Appeal
    Clearly Erroneous
    Fresh Pepper?
    Side Salad
    The Wishbone
    Jeremy Blachman
    Overheard/Office
    Naked Drinking Coffee
    Legally Blonde
    Legal Underground
    WSJ Law Blog
    The Slog
    Trivial Pusuits
    Still Angry
    Crooked Timber
    The Conglomerate
    Heldman: Ignatz
    Don't Let's Start
    Screaming Bean
    Heidi Bond
    Stag Blog
    Legal Quandary
    Divine Angst
    ObsessiveLawStudent
    Things Thrown
    The Imbroglio
    Signifying Nothing
    Stuart Buck
    Legal Fiction
    Under. Robes
    NRO's Corner
    New Republic
    Balkinization
    Election Law Blog
    Legal Theory Blog
    Legal Ethics Forum
    Ernie the Attorney
    Intel Dump
    Disability Law
    Bag & Baggage
    Between Lawyers
    Becker-Posner
    Lessig Blog
    Crim Prof Blog
    White Collar Crime
    Tax Prof Blog
    Grits for Breakfast
    All Deliberate Speed
    Adventures of Chester
    College Basketball Blog
    College Football News
    Nomination Nation
    Inter Alia
    Stateline
    The Note
    Wonkette
    The Onion
    Slate
    Atlantic
    RJYH: Fanopticon
    Freakonomics
    Vice Squad
    Indiana Law Blog
    Field of Schemes
    Questionable Content
    Dilbert Blog
    Toothpaste for Dinner
    Pathetic Geek Stories

    AIM: milbargebtq
    Yahoo: btqmilbarge

    Milbarge Recommends

    Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas
    Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas

    The Men Who Stare at Goats
    The Men Who Stare at Goats

    O.C.M.S.O.C.M.S.



    Site Feeds

    Subscribe with myFeedster
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe with Feed Burner
    Subscribe with Blogstreet

    Search
    Google
    Web BTQ
    Disclaimer

    The views presented here are personal and in no way reflect the view of my employer. In addition, while legal issues are discussed here from time to time, what you read at BTQ is not legal advice. I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer. If you need legal advice, then go see another lawyer.

    Furthermore, I reserve (and exercise) the right to edit or delete comments without provocation or warning. And just so we're clear, the third-party comments on this blog do not represent my views, nor does the existence of a comments section imply that said comments are endorsed by me.

    Technical Stuff

    Powered by Blogger
    FeedBurner.com

    Weblog Commenting by HaloScan.com

    Listed on Blogwise
    Blogarama - The Blog Directory
    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.



    < A Legally Inclined Weblog >