Begging The Question

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Maybe it was an amicus filing in the DC gun ban case...
Here's a tip: If you ask someone for directions to the U.S. Supreme Court building and say you have an appointment with the Chief Justice, it's probably not a smart idea to be carrying a loaded shotgun, a tactical bow and arrow, and a samurai sword. (Noted here at The Corner, Wonkette, and The Politico, but still waiting to see something on How Appealing, SCOTUSBlog, or even Above the Law.)

I was going to muse about how long it would take someone to mention that Tuesday is the thirty-fifth anniversary of Roe v. Wade, but I guess I just did. Clearly, this guy could have been motivated by just about anything. He was detained by the U.S. Capitol Police, so he may have been heading for that building. But I doubt I'll be the only one to notice the coincidence of timing (if that's all it is).

And of course, as I alluded to in the title of this post, this is all happening in the shadow (literally) of the DC gun ban case, scheduled to be argued later this term. Not that it would matter for the guy on a mission at the Court today. Even the government takes the position that an individual rights interpretation of the Second Amendment would permit the criminalization of the possession of guns by felons (the charge this guy is facing). I'm not sure where they come down on bows and arrows, though.



Monday, January 14, 2008

50 Book Challenge #2: Heartsick
Heartsick by Chelsea Cain. (Amazon, B&N, Powell's) After Entertainment Weekly called this one a "profoundly creepy thriller," I picked up the audio version (read by Midland, Texas's own Carolyn McCormick). It was good enough that there were several times when I sat in my car and waited for a scene to end before I could turn it off. So that's my review: "Heartsick is good enough to make you pollute!"

Now, if I were a clever book reviewer, I would figure out a way to transition from that image to note that the killer terrorizing Portland, Oregon, in Cain's mystery uses bleach to clean up after his crimes. This guy -- dubbed the After School Strangler -- kidnaps, rapes, and kills high school girls. So the police convene a task force. Luckily, they already had one together for their previous serial killer, the Beauty Killer, the lovely and evil Gretchen Lowell. Lowell tortured and killed scores before targeting the head of the task force, Archie Sheridan. Lowell kidnaps and tortures Archie, but ends up letting him live and turning herself in. (We learn about her reasons and the after-effects on Archie as the book progresses.) Two years later, Archie is barely functional and addicted to pain medication, but they need him again to catch the After School Strangler.

Our entree into all this is when newbie reporter Susan Ward (who has some issues of her own) is invited to follow the task force for a series in the paper. Susan realizes that the real story is the continuing, bizarre relationship between Archie and Gretchen Lowell. You'll think this is a gender-flipping Silence of the Lambs ripoff, but Gretchen has no interest in helping Archie catch the new killer.

I'd say that overall, I liked Heartsick. The twist wasn't jaw-droppingly surprising, but the story was suspenseful, and for the most part, well-told. (Cain does a good job building tension by jumping back and forth between the chase for the After School Killer and Archie's torture at Gretchen's hands, but she needs a synonym for "palpable"). It's really all about the characters, though, and here Heartsick is a winner. The three main characters are fully-formed and fully human. It's rare to see protagonists so flawed, and with flaws that really are flaws, and not the kind of "flaws" you tell an interviewer you have ("I'm a perfectionist!"). All in all, it's pretty good -- I would compare it favorably to the Michael Connelly I've read -- and I would recommend it if you're into serial killer/police thrillers.

(Previous 50 Book Challenge reviews)



Recent Posts

  • Small Business Administration
  • Creative Defenses in Contract Litigation
  • Scratching the Itch
  • Watch porn. Live longer. (possibly get divorced)...
  • Random Thought of the Day
  • To Do List
  • Proves the Rule
  • (Audio)Book Recommendation?
  • And now his head...is shaped like a tread
  • Whatever you say


  • Milbarge's links

    How Appealing
    Volokh Conspiracy
    Crescat Sententia
    Sugar, Mr. Poon?
    SCOTUSblog
    E. McPan
    Southern Appeal
    Stay of Execution
    S.W. Va. Law Blog
    CrimLaw
    Sentencing L&P
    Begging to Differ
    Prettier Than Napoleon
    Favorable Dicta
    The Yin Blog
    De Novo
    PG: HtSoM
    Centinel
    Hot Librarian
    Blonde Justice
    Althouse
    PrawfsBlawg
    Concurring Opinions
    Crime & Federalism
    Orin Kerr
    Is That Legal?
    Prof. Bainbridge
    Frolics & Detours
    AppellateLaw&Practice
    Right Coast
    Abstract Appeal
    Clearly Erroneous
    Fresh Pepper?
    Side Salad
    The Wishbone
    Jeremy Blachman
    Overheard/Office
    Naked Drinking Coffee
    Legally Blonde
    Legal Underground
    WSJ Law Blog
    The Slog
    Trivial Pusuits
    Still Angry
    Crooked Timber
    The Conglomerate
    Heldman: Ignatz
    Don't Let's Start
    Screaming Bean
    Heidi Bond
    Stag Blog
    Legal Quandary
    Divine Angst
    ObsessiveLawStudent
    Things Thrown
    The Imbroglio
    Signifying Nothing
    Stuart Buck
    Legal Fiction
    Under. Robes
    NRO's Corner
    New Republic
    Balkinization
    Election Law Blog
    Legal Theory Blog
    Legal Ethics Forum
    Ernie the Attorney
    Intel Dump
    Disability Law
    Bag & Baggage
    Between Lawyers
    Becker-Posner
    Lessig Blog
    Crim Prof Blog
    White Collar Crime
    Tax Prof Blog
    Grits for Breakfast
    All Deliberate Speed
    Adventures of Chester
    College Basketball Blog
    College Football News
    Nomination Nation
    Inter Alia
    Stateline
    The Note
    Wonkette
    The Onion
    Slate
    Atlantic
    RJYH: Fanopticon
    Freakonomics
    Vice Squad
    Indiana Law Blog
    Field of Schemes
    Questionable Content
    Dilbert Blog
    Toothpaste for Dinner
    Pathetic Geek Stories

    AIM: milbargebtq
    Yahoo: btqmilbarge

    Milbarge Recommends

    Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas
    Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas

    The Men Who Stare at Goats
    The Men Who Stare at Goats

    O.C.M.S.O.C.M.S.



    Site Feeds

    Subscribe with myFeedster
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe with Feed Burner
    Subscribe with Blogstreet

    Search
    Google
    Web BTQ
    Disclaimer

    The views presented here are personal and in no way reflect the view of my employer. In addition, while legal issues are discussed here from time to time, what you read at BTQ is not legal advice. I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer. If you need legal advice, then go see another lawyer.

    Furthermore, I reserve (and exercise) the right to edit or delete comments without provocation or warning. And just so we're clear, the third-party comments on this blog do not represent my views, nor does the existence of a comments section imply that said comments are endorsed by me.

    Technical Stuff

    Powered by Blogger
    FeedBurner.com

    Weblog Commenting by HaloScan.com

    Listed on Blogwise
    Blogarama - The Blog Directory
    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.



    < A Legally Inclined Weblog >