Begging The Question

Thursday, December 14, 2006

Parole Propaganda
News reports today inform us that Omar Abdel-Rahman, the "blind cleric" who plotted the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, is in poor health and had to be hospitalized last week. He's now back at his permanent home at the federal superdupermax prison in Colorado. Given Rahman's probably-imminent death, the FBI is nervous that he could inspire more terror attacks as an homage of sorts.

I have a suggestion: Release him.

Why not? Have the warden hand Rahman a fifty and a bus ticket and say, "Stay outta trouble!" Grant him a geriatric parole and tell him to report to a probation officer to commence his term of supervised release. I think this would serve several useful purposes.

First, propaganda. The U.S. could say it isn't heartless, and could say it is motivated by a desire to prevent terror attacks and not a desire to make old men suffer. (This could be coupled well with a gesture like releasing a handful of obviously harmless prisoners from Guantanamo.) And, the U.S. would avoid the charge that Rahman "died in U.S. custody." While the exact location of the man's expiration would hardly matter to terrorists committed to carrying out an attack in Rahman's name, it's less potent to say something like "died peacefully in his sleep" as opposed to "was already cold and stiff by morning roll call." Even if they put him on a plane to Egypt (his birthplace), my understanding is that the Egyptians have co-operated with the U.S. before in dealing with terrorists, and tracking his movements somewhere else would avoid legalistic concerns over domestic spying.

Second, I think it's probably safe to say that U.S. authorities have probably gotten from Rahman all the intelligence info they could by now. But if they let him go, what a bonanza! They'd probably like to know who Rahman would call, who would come pick him up, where they would go, where Rahman would live, who would support him, etc. I doubt that Rahman's followers, who cared enough about him to commit murder on his orders, would let him fend for himself like Brooks in Shawshank. So let him go and see where he leads.

I think Rahman could be more valuable to the U.S. outside of prison than in it, and that's not just because releasing him would save the expense of transporting him and caring for him as his condition worsens. To be clear, I'm mostly joking, and I don't wish Rahman any peace. But at some point, isn't it at least worth asking if detainees would serve us better as living tracking devices instead of as p.r. nightmares at Guantanamo?



Monday, December 11, 2006

Have a Carpal Tunnel Christmas
I think E. McPan has me beat in terms of volume, but my Christmas winter holiday cards are more colorful! Also unlike her, I won't offer to send you folks one, partly because my hand is crampy after all that well-wishing and addressing, and partly because I'm not sure how well I want to know some of you. That said, I will extend BTQ's best wishes to you and yours during whatever you're celebrating these days. Note: Not a guarantee of good tidings; some investments lose value; your mileage may vary; offer not valid in Wyoming and where prohibited by law; no purchase necessary.



Recent Posts

  • Number 5 is Alive!
  • Update on Shaq's Right to Possess a Gun
  • Coming Next Year: Sesame Street, Melrose Place, an...
  • The Winner: America
  • What's the matter with Ohio?
  • Notes From a Road Trip
  • Billy Packer's Election Analysis
  • Decoys?!?!
  • Can anybody spare a podcast?
  • Not one to put on your resume


  • Milbarge's links

    How Appealing
    Volokh Conspiracy
    Crescat Sententia
    Sugar, Mr. Poon?
    SCOTUSblog
    E. McPan
    Southern Appeal
    Stay of Execution
    S.W. Va. Law Blog
    CrimLaw
    Sentencing L&P
    Begging to Differ
    Prettier Than Napoleon
    Favorable Dicta
    The Yin Blog
    De Novo
    PG: HtSoM
    Centinel
    Hot Librarian
    Blonde Justice
    Althouse
    PrawfsBlawg
    Concurring Opinions
    Crime & Federalism
    Orin Kerr
    Is That Legal?
    Prof. Bainbridge
    Frolics & Detours
    AppellateLaw&Practice
    Right Coast
    Abstract Appeal
    Clearly Erroneous
    Fresh Pepper?
    Side Salad
    The Wishbone
    Jeremy Blachman
    Overheard/Office
    Naked Drinking Coffee
    Legally Blonde
    Legal Underground
    WSJ Law Blog
    The Slog
    Trivial Pusuits
    Still Angry
    Crooked Timber
    The Conglomerate
    Heldman: Ignatz
    Don't Let's Start
    Screaming Bean
    Heidi Bond
    Stag Blog
    Legal Quandary
    Divine Angst
    ObsessiveLawStudent
    Things Thrown
    The Imbroglio
    Signifying Nothing
    Stuart Buck
    Legal Fiction
    Under. Robes
    NRO's Corner
    New Republic
    Balkinization
    Election Law Blog
    Legal Theory Blog
    Legal Ethics Forum
    Ernie the Attorney
    Intel Dump
    Disability Law
    Bag & Baggage
    Between Lawyers
    Becker-Posner
    Lessig Blog
    Crim Prof Blog
    White Collar Crime
    Tax Prof Blog
    Grits for Breakfast
    All Deliberate Speed
    Adventures of Chester
    College Basketball Blog
    College Football News
    Nomination Nation
    Inter Alia
    Stateline
    The Note
    Wonkette
    The Onion
    Slate
    Atlantic
    RJYH: Fanopticon
    Freakonomics
    Vice Squad
    Indiana Law Blog
    Field of Schemes
    Questionable Content
    Dilbert Blog
    Toothpaste for Dinner
    Pathetic Geek Stories

    AIM: milbargebtq
    Yahoo: btqmilbarge

    Milbarge Recommends

    Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas
    Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas

    The Men Who Stare at Goats
    The Men Who Stare at Goats

    O.C.M.S.O.C.M.S.



    Site Feeds

    Subscribe with myFeedster
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe with Feed Burner
    Subscribe with Blogstreet

    Search
    Google
    Web BTQ
    Disclaimer

    The views presented here are personal and in no way reflect the view of my employer. In addition, while legal issues are discussed here from time to time, what you read at BTQ is not legal advice. I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer. If you need legal advice, then go see another lawyer.

    Furthermore, I reserve (and exercise) the right to edit or delete comments without provocation or warning. And just so we're clear, the third-party comments on this blog do not represent my views, nor does the existence of a comments section imply that said comments are endorsed by me.

    Technical Stuff

    Powered by Blogger
    FeedBurner.com

    Weblog Commenting by HaloScan.com

    Listed on Blogwise
    Blogarama - The Blog Directory
    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.



    < A Legally Inclined Weblog >