Begging The Question

Maybe the two of us, working together at full capacity, could do the job of one normal man.
Home
About
Contact
Archives
Celeb Endorsements
Sunday, February 08, 2004

The BTQ Review: Positively Fifth Street
As part of our sporadic review feature, I'd like to present Positively Fifth Street: Murderers, Cheetahs, and Binion's World Series of Poker by James McManus (paperback available next month, I think).

McManus was a writer and amateur poker player when, in 2000, he scored a gig with Harper's magazine to cover the World Series of Poker in Las Vegas (specifically, to cover the women who were now competing with the best of the male poker players), and the murder trial arising out of the death of Ted Binion, black sheep of the family whose casino hosts the poker event, Binion's Horseshoe. In a bizarre congruence, the trial of Binion's ex-stripper ex-girlfriend and her new lover took place at the same time as the 2000 WSOP. McManus, struggling in his conscience between "Good Jim" the family fan and "Bad Jim" the gambler, uses his advance from Harper's and a future mortgage payment or two and joins the tournament.

And while McManus might have merely thought it would make for a better story to go Gonzo and try to bluff some of his subjects, he ends up outplaying almost all of the 500+ entrants that year (there were over 800 this year) to wind up at the final table. In the midst of this phenomenal run for an amateur (hell, for anybody), he tracks down the sordid story of Ted Binion and his killers. The book begins with McManus's reconstruction of the murder, and the reader is immediately drawn into the alternate universe that Vegas seems to be. People just go there and lose their minds, or, for the unlucky ones like Ted Binion, their lives. And despite the family-friendly image the Vegas tourism folks have been painting recently, it becomes quite clear that parts of that town are still squarely in the Wild West.

Over the course of the book, McManus (as "Bad Jim") starts to identify more and more with Binion, and he realizes how easy it would be to let the demons of the psyche loose for a night on the town. Of course, success in poker is all about not "going on tilt" and keeping oneself calm when one is in the midst of a euphoric victory or a crushing defeat. There's a lot of interesting stuff in the book about the psychology of playing high-stakes poker, and the psycho-sexual-sadism that's a little bit necessary for the game, or at least accompanies big successes and big failures much of the time.

I'm not much of a gambler; I'm a pretty risk-averse person. I spent a day in Vegas once and quit after losing six dollars. I've played a little poker, and understand the basics, but not the many nuances one must master to win even one hand against the pros. But Positively Fifth Street is still enjoyable for the novice or (I think) even the non-player. McManus explains the basics of Texas No-Limit Hold'em, the biggest game in the WSOP, with multi-million dollar purses. The book includes a glossary of poker terminology if you get lost, and there's an extensive bibilography if you're looking for more about the game.

But even without following all the details, anyone can understand when a player gets lucky after raising when he shouldn't have, or gets unlucky when he had the best hand until the last card fell. You understand when Bad Jim takes over and raises with nothing against poker legend T.J. Cloutier, and gets the card he needs, prompting the even-more legendary Amarillo Slim Preston to declare that McManus "has the heart of a cliff-diver."

Well, I won't say that Positively Fifth Street takes you to the top of the cliff with him, but it's a very enjoyable read. A book that would have worked pretty well either as a tale of a poker tournament or as the story of a love gone bad leading to murder works very well exploring the confluence of the two. And its publication was timed perfectly to ride the wave of popularity that big-money poker is on now. (Although, given that there was a skit tonight on Saturday Night Live parodying Bravo's celebrity poker tv show, perhaps it has jumped the shark....)

A quick word about the play on words in the title, in case you didn't get it. "Fifth Street" is the colloquial name for the final card played in a hand of Texas Hold'em. Positively Fourth Street is a Bob Dylan song, and I wonder if McManus was thinking about this lyric when he coined his pun:

You got a lotta nerve
To say you are my friend.
When I was down
You just stood there grinning.

You got a lotta nerve
To say you got a helping hand to lend.
You just want to be on
The side that's winning.

The players get friendly, and there is certainly a great deal of respect for each other's ability. But the smart poker player knows a smile can hide a bluff, and the most popular guy at the table is the one who just lost.

Look, this book has money, cowboys, murder, lap dances, and a Sicilian judge presiding over a trial in the desert. What more could you want? I had so much fun reading it, I'm going to give it our highest rating, a full six-pack.





"Milbarge shot Bambi." -- Will Baude

"BTQ may, in fact, be the most important website... Ever." -- Mr. Poon

"They're a strange duo, but in a cool way." -- SA's Feddie


Open links in new windows?

Recent Posts

  • Milbarge: The Authorized Biography
  • Fitz-Hume: the authorized biography
  • Still Merry
  • Only 5 days left until I get to vote against Wesley Clark. Ye-aaaaaagh!
  • Sometimes that Goldberg guy gets it right, err, I mean correct.
  • The future is now! was yesterday
  • Modern Bride Magazine Selling Like Hotcakes in Massachusetts
  • Not The Mile-High Club You Want To Join
  • The Otis Campbell of Sacramento
  • America's #1 Boob


  • Milbarge's links

    Ctrl + F5

    How Appealing
    Volokh Conspiracy
    Crescat Sententia
    Sugar, Mr. Poon?
    S.W. Va. Law Blog
    CrimLaw
    SCOTUSblog
    Life, Law, Libido
    Legal Theory Blog
    Stay of Execution
    Sentencing L&P

    Alt + Back

    Is That Legal?
    Lone Star Expat
    BBQ & Daycare
    Begging to Differ
    TauntingHappyFunBall
    Jeremy Blachman
    Legal Underground
    Election Law Blog
    Ernie the Attorney
    Intel Dump
    The Yin Blog
    Slithery D
    E. McPan
    Centinel
    Trivial Pusuits
    Favorable Dicta
    Southern Appeal
    Running With Lawyers
    Naked Drinking Coffee
    Season of Mists
    Three Years of Hell
    Legal Fiction

    Alt + Tab

    Slate
    NRO's Corner
    De Novo
    Stateline
    Blog 702
    The Note
    Wonkette
    The Onion
    Vice Squad
    The Idea Shop
    Ditzy Genius
    Under. Robes
    Sua Sponte
    Abstract Appeal
    Criminal Appeal
    Direct Appeal
    Second Opinions
    Texas Law Blog
    Naked Ownership
    Naked Furniture
    Dave Barry
    Fed Lawyer Guy
    Overlawyered
    Balkinization
    Indiana Law Blog
    Field of Schemes
    Daily Whirl
    Unbillable Hours
    Bag & Baggage
    Curmudgeonly Clerk
    The Buck Stops Here
    4thAmendment.com
    Pathetic Geek Stories
    Statutory Constr. Zone

    Fitz-Hume's Links

    RealClearPolitics
    NRO's Corner
    Slate
    New Republic
    The Note
    Belmont Club
    Strategy Page
    Defend America
    Poynter Online
    NEPA blog

    Volokh Conspiracy
    The Right Coast
    Southern Appeal
    Life, Law, Libido
    The Commons
    Begging to Differ
    Signifying Nothing
    The Yin Blog
    Trivial Pursuits
    Inclination to Criticize
    Sgt. Stryker
    Citizen Smash
    Clear Thinkers
    Boots & Sabers
    PHOSITA
    Crescat Sententia

    Lileks
    Intel Dump
    Informed Comment
    The Buck Stops Here
    Countercolumn
    How Appealing
    S.W. Va. Law Blog
    Sugar, Mr. Poon?
    Ernie the Attorney
    BBQ & Day Care
    Slithery D
    TauntingHappyFunBall
    Hobbesian Conserv.
    Centinel
    Favorable Dicta
    Lone Star Expat
    One Hand Clapping
    CrimLaw
    NDC
    Wings & Vodka
    Bayou City Perspective
    Lawyers, Guns & Money
    Running with Lawyers
    Mudville Gazette
    Statutory Constr. Zone
    Tech Law Advisor
    Random Mentality
    Unbillable Hours
    Menagerie

    All Deliberate Speed
    Mediocrity's Co-Pilot
    A Season of Mists
    Wilson's Blog
    CommaCommaSemicolon
    Blue Ridge Blog
    Malaland
    Manifest Border
    All Things Jen(nifer)
    Andrew Raff
    Emily!
    Half-Cocked
    Jaded JD
    Law Pundit
    Matt Schuh
    michaelscaljon
    Observant Little Sh*t
    Not For Sheep
    Quo Vado
    Sagamoric Musings
    stag

    Milbarge Recommends

    Bully: Does Anyone Deserve to Die?
    Bully: Does Anyone Deserve to Die?

    Barman: Ping-Pong, Pathos, and Passing the Bar
    Barman: Ping-Pong, Pathos, and Passing the Bar



    Site Feeds

    Subscribe with myFeedster
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe with Feed Burner
    Subscribe with Blogstreet
    Add http://beggingthequestion.com to your Kinja digest

    Search
    Google
    Web BTQ
    Disclaimer

    The views presented here are personal and in no way reflect the views of our employers. In fact, the views expressed on this site are not endorsed by us. Unless, of course, they are. In addition, while legal issues are discussed here from time to time, what you read at BTQ is not legal advice. We are lawyers, but we are not your lawyers. If you need legal advice, then go see another lawyer.

    Furthermore, we reserve (and exercise) the right to edit or delete comments without provocation or warning. And just so we're clear, the third-party comments on this blog do not represent our views, nor does the existence of a comments section imply that said comments are endorsed by us. Unless, of course, they are.

    Credits

    may*star: girl + designs
    Powered by Blogger
    FeedBurner.com
    Weblog Commenting by HaloScan.com

    Listed on Blogwise
    Blogarama - The Blog Directory
    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.






    Listed on BlogShares


    < A Legally Inclined Weblog >

    template by maystar * designs